Home

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This Week's Column

Visit the Archives

Subscribe to the Column

Biography

Book Info

Feedback

 

 

 

 

The Weekly Fare . . . February 24, 2005

Being Boiled Alive Does Not Hurt
(And Other Scientific Findings)

The big news last week as far as I can tell (outside of the fact that The Roanoke Times has become interested in "investigative reporting") is that lobsters do not - I repeat do not - feel pain when dropped in boiling water. This, as certified by the University of Oslow (Norway) and as reported by just about every news service in America.

This conclusion was reached in spite of the fact that lobsters tend to thrash about rather violently when dropped into boiling water and that, in general, scalding water tends to hurt like hell.

But who am I to suggest that the Oslonians got it all wrong - after all, the THIRTY NINE PAGE REPORT (was it double spaced I wonder?) sounds pretty, well, scientific like.

"Lobsters and crabs have some ability to learn but it is unlikely they feel pain."

And you know this because?

"Because, like their close relatives - clams, crabs and what not, they can't really think . . . at least as far as we can tell . . ."

Can't really think? Have you ever gone crabbing and had one get loose on the dock? Grown men scatter as though their underwear is on fire and whoever remains to take on the "stupid crab" either winds up in the drink, or with their adversary dangling painfully from one or more extremities. From witnessing years of such encounters (and losing a few myself) I can tell you with confidence, which is the superior species.

And answer me this Sven and Bjorn - How do crabs know to proceed to the closest possible dock edge even though they: A.) Have never been on a dock before. B.) Can't see the edge behind them and C.) Have only half a nanosecond to "think" about it?

Who's kidding whom here?

Perhaps these Norwegians have ulterior motives . . .

My friend Buzz Brown and I purchased a couple of live Maine lobsters one rainy Saturday afternoon while my parents were out of town. We had very little to do and we figured we'd play with them a while and then cook them up for dinner once we got hungry. Lucky for "Clyde" and "Ernesto" we had had a rather late lunch so they were able to enjoy a good long scamper on the patio in the rain while we lounged around inside watching them through the kitchen window.

In the name of "sport", we eventually took off the little rubber bands that covered their pinchers (lobsters being so stupid, they try to pinch things that want to eat them). It seemed like a perfectly good idea at the time, but as I recall they took out a couple of Mom's geraniums and proved to be extremely difficult to coral once dinnertime arrived. Truthfully, if it hadn't been for a pair of rather long handled salad tongs, I believe that Buzz and I would have been summarily outwitted. (Not that this would have been indicative of any particular intelligence on the lobster's part mind you.)

My then girlfriend and soon to be wife was on hand for at least some of this display of human superiority and had strongly advised that we not name them - nor give them room to run around the patio and ultimately into our hearts. Being the manly sort of men we were, however, we weren't particularly worried about becoming attached to these two lowly crustaceans. But as I recall, more than one tear was shed when my dear Ernesto finally hit the pot . . .

He was such a good boy.

Tasted pretty darn good too, though, as I recall.

A University of Maine scientist eager to support the recent report and his Lobster catching brethren across the Atlantic, also responded in purely scientific, albeit American, fashion . . .

"It's a semantic thing," said Mike Loughlin, "no brain, no pain."

How's that for taking thirty-nine pages of uninspired, un-provable scientific chatter and condensing it into eight small words. Kind of, dare I say, like a good chowder - the very best parts, seasoned and presented in a minimalist, yet delectably succinct fashion . . . (Though I suspect Mr. Loughlin's comment didn't further endear us to the balance of Europe, which doesn't seem to appreciate such concise and forthright language.)

So there it is. Being boiled alive does not hurt - provided you're stupid enough.

It therefore seems likely we could toss a few Norwegians scientists and at least two Americans into the pot and have absolutely nothing to worry about.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page by UNCARVED.NET