FEB. 3, 2000
Something Old,
Something New
By STUART
REVERCOMB
My neighbor called me
the other day. She needed to borrow something.
It was a chain saw.
Perhaps I was a bit
chauvinistic in my response because I likely would not have questioned
her husband as to what exactly HE needed it for, but because it was Tuesday
afternoon and she's not exactly a Paul Bunyon-just-feel like-laying-some-timber-down-kind
of gal, I inquired :
"What are you going
to do with a chain saw, Arline?"
"Well ..."
she said with the hint of a giggle. "It's these damn boxwoods."
There was a pause and then her voice deepened with determination, "They've
got to go." She said that last part with enough conviction that I
knew those bushes were in some serious trouble.
"Boxwoods?"
I asked. "You mean the tall, perfect, beautiful, stately, 78-year-old
boxwoods that adorn so nicely the front of your perfect house."
"Oh, no! You're
one of them!" she gasped, fearing that I, too, was going to cast
her into the mental well reserved for such social outcast who would dare
bring an unnatural demise to a "Buxwood."
"Just kidding,"
I said, trying to picture the boxwoods around their house. "Is something
wrong with them -- disease or something -- or are they simply in the way?"
She waffled pretty heavily
for a moment, speaking briefly of potential root damage to the foundation
of her 80-year-old house, but then she came clean in a moment of exasperation:
"They're just too big," she repeated herself, "They're
just too big and they've got to go."
Not one to decide too
quickly the pulling of a day-old volunteer daisy in the middle of the
patio, she could sense my reservation when it came to being an accomplice
in the spontaneous obliteration of 70 years of natural growth. I thought
for a moment. There is something rather sacred about such a shrub and
the boxwoods around her house did look kind of nice. "You SURE you
want to chain saw those bushes, Arline?"
"What is the deal
with boxwoods around here? she exclaimed. "It's like a religion or
something!"
She was on to me.
"Do you have a
chain saw or not?"
Lucky for those boxwoods,
I didn't. "No," I said, not mentioning that I had a hand saw
that would likely do the job. "Thanks anyways," she said. Those
boxwoods were history and I knew it.
I was glad those big,
beautiful overgrown bushes weren't in front of my house. I probably wouldn't
be brave enough to whack 'em. What would all those Boxwoodians say? And
what if I stepped back it looked WAY worse than before? Seventy-eight
years gone -- whacked down in a moment by Stuart H. Revercomb -- guilty
for all time. The open gap and scarred earth would leave no doubt. I was
a Boxwood Killer.
My children would have
few friends.
Arline and I enjoyed
a good laugh over her "boxwood decision" and I knew we would
probably enjoy the mirth of the moment for many years to come, but an
age-old question had presented itself once again.
When does tradition
become an overzealous lust for the past that gets in the way of beneficial
and badly needed progress -- the sort of change that brings new and vibrant
life in place of that which is old and staid?
And when are we cutting
down the irreplaceable beauty and grace of our own history that offers
so much more than mere function?
It's often a very hard
call.
I've followed with great
interest Roanoke City's recent parks proposal that involves the possible
demolition of Victory Stadium: a 58-year-old, 26,000 seat outdoor stadium
on the banks of the Roanoke River. The committee has recommended we take
a chain saw to the stadium and replace it with a much smaller one because
the old one is "dilapidated" and "there's no way we will
ever need one as big as we presently have." In the coming weeks I
hope all those involved will wrestle hard with the possibilities.
The stadium is made
of concrete, mortar and brick each with a half life of about 250,000 years.
What, pray tell, is so dilapidated? And why will it take an estimated
$15 million to "fix it"? Are we just not as satisfied with what
once passed as a pretty decent public sports facility? Wouldn't a couple
of million for renovated rest rooms and locker rooms do the trick? What's
the bid for all new seating? This is the kind of information that voters
need to voice an informed opinion.
Why rip down the existing
stadium to begin with? Heck, build the new one next door or on some other
parcel in the valley. Then we've saved the million dollar-plus demolition
costs, we've got our brand new smaller facility and we still have the
larger beautiful old brick stadium to boot -- and we're able to fulfill
roles we never could otherwise. Rupert Cutler suggested that the new stadium
be built next to the Roanoke Civic Center to take advantage of existing
parking -- perhaps at the present location of Magic City Ford. This is
one of many ideas worth exploring.
If you dig into the
archive and read last week's column you will
see a section that highlights several "far-sighted comments"
by leading public figures, one of which was made by Bill Gates, who in
1981 remarked that "640K ought to be enough for anybody." The
statement by a committee member regarding stadium size would have fit
right in.
"There's no way
we will ever need one as big as we presently have," he said.
And 640K wouldn't hold
a tenth of this web site. Who's to say what we'll need five to 15 years
from now.
On April 19, 1998, the
Dave Mathews Band kicked off their World Concert Tour at Victory Stadium.
Some guy named Bruce Hornsby played a song or two as well. It was attended
by more than 31,000 people and was highlighted in the media and among
many of Roanoke's younger business leaders as the best, most progressive
event of its kind in recent Roanoke history. The city estimated that its
direct revenues from the concert were over $200,000 and a conservative
estimate for local businesses would be in the $750,000 range. In addition
an astounding $500,000 was raised for charities. That should speak reasonably
well of the future potential of such a facility.
Sometimes honoring the
past helps you face the future -- as in the case of Roanoke's old stadium.
Sometimes it gets in
the way.
Good job, Arline. The
yard looks great.
|